You Qualify for a Green Card. Why Isn’t Approval Automatic?
A couple has a genuine marriage, a shared home, and plans for their future. An employee has an employer willing to sponsor permanent residence. Both may reasonably think that once they qualify and submit the paperwork, a green card should follow.
But qualification is only part of the decision. For many people applying for permanent residence from inside the United States, USCIS must also decide whether to approve the application as a matter of discretion. That distinction deserves particular attention following the agency’s May 2026 policy memorandum.
Understanding it starts with separating three questions: Is there a basis for a green card? Can the person obtain it through adjustment of status? And does the case warrant approval?
What qualifying actually means
Adjustment of status is the process of obtaining permanent residence while remaining in the United States. In many family and employment cases, the application is Form I-485.
An approved family or employment petition does not, by itself, answer every question on that application. For adjustment under section 245(a) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, USCIS generally examines whether the applicant was inspected and admitted or paroled, whether an immigrant visa is available, and whether the person is admissible for permanent residence. Other restrictions and exceptions may apply. www.uscis.gov
“Admissibility” concerns legal grounds that can prevent admission or permanent residence, including certain immigration violations, criminal conduct, and fraud. Some grounds have waivers; others do not. A waiver is a separate request to excuse a particular legal obstacle, where the law permits it. www.ilrc.org
This is why two people with the same type of approved petition can face very different paths. Their entry records, prior applications, and immigration histories matter.
Why discretion is getting more attention
In a memorandum dated May 21, 2026, USCIS characterized adjustment under section 245 as “extraordinary relief” and emphasized consular processing abroad. It directed officers to weigh the full circumstances, including immigration violations, representations made to officials, and whether the applicant complied with the purpose and conditions of admission. The memorandum also acknowledges dual-intent categories—visa categories that accommodate both temporary stay and pursuit of permanent residence. assets.aila.org
Discretion itself is longstanding. USCIS’s Policy Manual describes it as an additional assessment, usually made after an applicant meets the threshold eligibility requirements. Eligibility and a favorable discretionary decision are separate questions. www.uscis.gov
The American Immigration Lawyers Association challenges the memorandum’s framing. In its policy brief, AILA argues that Congress created adjustment as an established statutory pathway and warns that the new approach could make that pathway harder to use. AILA also reports that members have encountered questions about why applicants did not depart and requests for evidence of family hardship and other favorable circumstances. Those are practitioner reports, not proof that every applicant will face the same treatment. www.aila.org
The practical concern is that a person may satisfy the legal requirements yet still need to address why USCIS should approve the case. The memorandum does not repeal section 245 or establish that every applicant must leave the country.
A marriage case shows why the distinction matters
Consider a hypothetical applicant who entered with a visa, later overstayed, and married a U.S. citizen. The marriage is genuine.
USCIS guidance recognizes exceptions to certain adjustment bars for immediate relatives of U.S. citizens, including bars involving unlawful status and unauthorized employment. Those exceptions can preserve an avenue to adjustment. They do not excuse every possible problem. www.uscis.gov
The couple still needs a review of the applicant’s entry and immigration history, any prior statements to the government, and other eligibility issues. The fact that a particular bar does not apply is a legal argument worth making. It should not be replaced with a vague promise that marriage “fixes everything.”
This example also shows why preparation must go beyond collecting wedding photographs. Evidence of the relationship serves one purpose. Addressing the applicant’s eligibility and any discretionary concerns serves another.
What useful evidence looks like
USCIS’s discretionary framework considers favorable and unfavorable circumstances in context. Depending on the case, relevant considerations can include family ties, hardship, employment, community involvement, immigration history, and rehabilitation following misconduct. iptp-production.s3.amazonaws.
The practical task is to document the circumstances that actually matter. If a spouse depends on the applicant for daily care, explain that responsibility and support it with appropriate records. If an employer describes the applicant’s contribution, the letter should identify the work and its importance. If an old incident raises concerns, obtain the records and address what happened and what followed.
General praise often leaves the important questions unanswered. A specific letter explaining a person’s responsibilities can be more useful than several letters calling the person hardworking.
More paperwork is not automatically better. The goal is a truthful, organized record that lets the officer understand the relevant facts. These examples are preparation suggestions, not a universal USCIS checklist.
Leaving the country is a separate legal decision
Headlines about consular processing can make departure sound like an administrative change: finish the same application somewhere else.
For some applicants, leaving can have serious consequences. USCIS explains that departure after certain periods of unlawful presence can trigger three- or ten-year grounds of inadmissibility. The analysis depends on the person’s history and applicable exceptions or waivers. www.uscis.gov
The Immigrant Legal Resource Center’s guidance on family-based adjustment also explains why the ability to apply within the United States matters: departure can involve separation from family and additional legal risks. www.ilrc.org
Before changing from adjustment to consular processing, an applicant needs an assessment of what departure would do to the case and the ability to return. Travel should not be based on a headline or another person’s experience.
Preparation starts with the full history
A useful review begins before filing. Gather prior immigration applications and decisions, entry and departure records, employment history, and any relevant court records. Identify inconsistencies while there is time to investigate and explain them. If a date or answer is uncertain, verify it rather than guess.
For a pending case, read any request for evidence carefully. Identify whether USCIS is questioning eligibility, admissibility, discretion, or more than one issue. Each requires a response directed to the actual concern.
The May memorandum instructs officers issuing discretionary denials to explain the positive and negative factors and why the negative factors outweigh the positive ones. A denial should therefore be examined for its reasoning, not simply its conclusion. mrfreedomusa.com
For families and employers, a green card represents the ability to plan a life or retain a valued colleague. A carefully prepared application should establish the legal basis for approval and give USCIS an accurate account of the circumstances it must weigh.
If you are preparing an adjustment application or have received a request questioning your eligibility or circumstances, our office can review your immigration history and help identify the issues your case needs to address.
This article provides general information about adjustment of status, principally under INA section 245(a). Humanitarian and other adjustment categories may have different rules. It is not legal advice for an individual case.